Follow The Money, And You'll Find The Science
Methane Madness: The Profit-Driven War on Meat
The narrative surrounding methane’s role in climate change has reached an absurd fever pitch, fueled by exaggerated claims, questionable science, and convenient policy interventions designed to profit powerful industries. Central to this story is methane—a trace gas in the atmosphere—blamed for catastrophic warming despite its minuscule concentration and overlapping absorption capabilities with much more abundant greenhouse gases like water vapor.
This crusade against methane, particularly in agriculture, reveals how climate change is being weaponized to generate profit while dismantling traditional meat production systems. Let’s dive into the science, debunk the myths, and expose how corporations are profiting from manufactured crises.
Methane in Perspective: A Trace Gas with a Trace Impact
Methane (CH₄) is present in the atmosphere at an average concentration of approximately 1.9 parts per million (ppm), often expressed as 1,900 parts per billion (ppb). To put this into context:
Carbon dioxide (CO₂): ~420 ppm.
Water vapor: ~10,000 to 40,000 ppm depending on location and humidity.
Methane’s relative concentration is minuscule… less than 0.0002% of the atmosphere.
While it’s true that methane can trap more heat per molecule than CO₂, this comparison ignores scale. The sheer abundance of water vapor and CO₂ renders methane’s overall impact marginal. Furthermore:
Methane’s Short Lifespan: Methane naturally breaks down in the atmosphere within about a decade, converting into CO₂ and water vapor through oxidation.
Saturated Effect: The warming potential of methane diminishes rapidly as its absorption bands overlap with those of water vapor.
In other words, methane plays a minor role in the global energy balance, making the hysterical focus on it scientifically unjustified.
Why CO₂ Doesn’t Block Sunlight: Debunking Common Myths
One question often asked is whether CO₂ blocks incoming sunlight, given its role in trapping heat. The answer lies in the absorption spectrum, as illustrated in the figure.
Incoming Radiation: The Visible and UV Spectrum
The top portion of the diagram shows the energy distribution of radiation emitted by the Sun (in orange), which peaks in the visible range (approximately 0.4 to 0.7 µm) and extends into the ultraviolet (UV) and near-infrared ranges. Most of the Sun’s energy that reaches Earth is concentrated in this visible light spectrum, where neither CO₂ nor other greenhouse gases absorb significant amounts of radiation.
CO₂ Absorption Bands: As shown in the "Carbon dioxide" row, the primary absorption bands of CO₂ are located in the infrared range (10-15 µm). These bands are completely irrelevant for incoming solar radiation, which predominantly falls outside these wavelengths.
Water Vapor and Other Gases: Water vapor and ozone play a larger role in absorbing UV and some visible light, but even their influence is minor compared to their role in absorbing Earth's outgoing infrared radiation.
In short, incoming sunlight easily passes through the atmosphere because it is largely unaffected by greenhouse gases like CO₂. This allows solar radiation to reach Earth's surface and warm it.
Outgoing Radiation: The Infrared Spectrum
The story changes entirely when looking at the outgoing radiation emitted by Earth, represented by the blue curve in the infrared spectrum. Here, CO₂’s absorption bands (centered around 15 µm) align well with the wavelengths of heat radiated by Earth's surface. This is why CO₂ is effective at slowing heat escape, it absorbs outgoing radiation, not incoming sunlight.
Methane’s Overlap with Water Vapor: A Saturated Spectrum
Methane’s absorption spectrum provides further evidence that its warming potential is exaggerated. Methane absorbs infrared radiation in specific bands (3-8 µm and around 7-8 µm), but these regions are already dominated by water vapor, which is far more abundant. In essence, water vapor absorbs the majority of the available radiation in these wavelengths, leaving little for methane to trap.
Even if methane concentrations were to double or triple, the additional warming effect would be negligible due to this saturation. This basic physical principle undermines the catastrophic rhetoric about methane’s role in climate change. The science simply does not support the extreme claims being made.
Manufactured Alarmism: Targeting Methane to Scapegoat Farmers
Despite the science, methane emissions—particularly from livestock—have become the focus of alarmist narratives. Headlines proclaim methane is “80 times more powerful than CO₂” over a 20-year period, conveniently ignoring its short lifespan and the diminishing returns of increased concentrations.
This rhetoric has made agriculture, especially cattle farming, an easy target. Livestock are natural methane emitters through digestion, a process known as enteric fermentation, yet their impact on global emissions remains a fraction of that caused by fossil fuel combustion.
The demonization of livestock farming is not driven by scientific necessity but by economic and ideological agendas. Methane has become a convenient scapegoat, paving the way for profit-driven interventions and policies that penalize traditional farmers while benefiting large corporations.
Punishing Farmers, Profiting Corporations: The Role of Policy
Governments around the world are introducing aggressive policies to curb methane emissions, ranging from outright bans on certain farming practices to financial penalties on livestock farmers. For example:
New Zealand has proposed taxing farmers for methane emissions from livestock, despite its population being heavily reliant on agriculture.
The EU and the U.S. are promoting methane reduction strategies tied to “green” funding initiatives, such as subsidies for alternative proteins and lab-grown meat.
These policies claim to address methane's environmental impact but ultimately penalize traditional farmers, driving them toward expensive technological fixes or out of business altogether.
Bovaer: The “Solution” with Troubling Risks
DSM-Firmenich, in partnership with Elanco, has developed Bovaer, a feed additive marketed as a revolutionary solution for reducing methane emissions in cattle. This additive works…
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Irrational Fear to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.